The verdict on the Reese’s International Delight coffee creamer: 😕. Though it smells chocolatey, it tastes like artificial peanut butter and nothing like Reese’s. I used as much creamer as it took to achieve this color, plus one stevia packet, and Reese’s didn’t dance through my brain ever. Wasn’t gross though. You’d need to add a lotttt of creamer to really make this close, or perhaps just add all the candy I’ve laid out here to fill space for a photo. 6/10 max 💔
There appears to be a massive trend of peanut butter-laced sweets going around in the dessert world right now. We’ve recently seen Reese’s Peanut Butter Doughnuts drop at Krispy Kreme, PB&J Oreos have appeared at Kroger stores around the country, and it now appears that that fad has spread into the beverage section, specifically for coffee creamers.
PopSugar independently confirmed with Walmart that a Reese’s-flavored Coffee Creamer was being sold by International Delight. The coffee creamer brand, which has made creamers out of chocolates like Almond Joy in the past, will also be selling the new peanut butter coffee addition in other stores, as well. While not all of those are known yet, at least one fan of candy-snooping blogger The Impulsive Buy has mentioned purchasing the new creamer at 7-11.
Sadly, early reviews of the new flavor claim that it doesn’t really taste much like Reese’s iconic peanut butter cups at all. Still, it’ll be interesting to see how coffee and peanut butter go together, so we’re still gonna go and try this out for ourselves.