After our weekend of research and poll results, hundreds of votes were cast in the battle of Nutella vs. Peanut Butter. While the results were close, the versatility and flavor of Peanut Butter captured 55.42% of the vote, with Nutella falling into 2nd place with a respectable 44.58% of the vote. The question asked of our readership was, “If you were on stranded on an island forever…would you bring Nutella, or Peanut Butter? The people have spoken. Peanut Butter is the ultimate island survivor spread.