Make Your Own Cookie Dough Magic Shell Topping

Who knew making your own magic shell ice cream topping could be so simple? Our new friend Katrina turned us on to her recipe for a Magic Shell Cookie Dough Ice Cream Topping, made with only two ingredients and a few minutes of spare kitchen time. The way her recipe is laid out, you can probably make some bulk amounts too…oh the possibilities.


Cookie Dough Magic Shell Topping


  1. ½ Cup coconut oil, melted
  2. ½ Cup Betty Crocker Chocolate Chip Cookie Ready-Made Mix 

(You can use any amounts, just use equal parts for best flavor.)


  1. Melt coconut oil and stir in dry mix.
  2. Let stand for about 20 minutes.
  3. Spoon over ice cream. Enjoy!

By Elie Ayrouth

Elie is a product of Orange County, CA. In early 2012, his dentist diagnosed him with 8 different cavities, three of which on the same tooth, as a result of his 23-year Sour Patch Kid addiction.

1 reply on “Make Your Own Cookie Dough Magic Shell Topping”

Leave a Reply